Diameter paths help

I am trying to figure this ongoing issue out.

I’m cutting diameter tool pathing using a quarter inch bit from IDC, caliper bit to ensure accuracy, confirmed.

I’m running the Makita router on my X 50, 48 x 32,

Currently reflashed the OS, to be sure that there was no hangups from previous versions of firmware, confirmed accurate upload

My tool path was set at .71 diameter with a .25 DOC, post operation, diameter is .66.

have repeatedly tried to accommodate different possible scenarios, except one, replace router.

before I do that, does anybody have any insight or suggestions?

If your intended diameter is .71" and your result is .66", then it’s not the router.

1 Like

You can do some test to determine if the culprit is machine deflection, or programming related.

To check for machine deflection…
Try making the hole, then running the same toolpath again, if new material is cut on the second run, its a signal that the cutter is deflecting.

Try running the cutter slower, and see if the diameter gets closer to your intended result. If so, the cutter is likely deflecting towards the center of the hole, creating a smaller diameter.

Try switching from “conventional” milling to “climb” milling (or vice versa) See if that helps. Again, this might indicate deflection.

If none of the above make any difference - the problem is more likely programming.

Cam software often uses a “leave stock on walls” option that you may have accidentally selected.

1 Like

.050 is a lot to be off, is the hole round or oblong, do you do a separate last pass say .005 per side, is there a lot of slop in the ball screws, can you move the router motor any way, front to back or side to side?
Pat

2 Likes

You don’t indicate your depth of cut and speed.
Also how long is the bit and is it straight?

1 Like

Thank you for the response. I have done each of the steps you suggested and I was not able to detect the deflection in the bit nor is there a difference in the hole after switching from climb to conventional.

I am at a loss…

Thank you for the response.

I am checking that now Ill update in a few minutes

Thank you

So today I did make the same vector and modified all the settings based on all the suggestions in the comments section of this post, I cut .75 at X-RPM (#3 on the turn dial for the Makita, sorry I dont have the rpm chart memorized and cannot recall the RPMs) So after modifying all the settings It is cutting at .69. using the Jenny upcut at .25 DOC

I am at a loss

intended diameter is .75 today and it cut at .69


So if you are using Vcarve there is a pocket allowance (bottom right of image) or there is a finish allowance in some of the other toolpaths

1 Like

weird…I would cut some round and square pockets and bosses to see if the outside measurements are off the same as inside.

I’ll try that now, great idea

I know that my friend. I don’t know what you are getting at?

No ill will just trying to help. I have seen some projects that turned out weird because a box was checked off that wasn’t supposed to be.

oh ok. thanks for offering help