Indeed there are many threads on this topic.
Some criteria that appear regularly:
- Platform? VCarve does not run natively on macOS (*)
- CAD/design? Fusion 360 integrates CAD and CAM
- Signs or boxes? Both can do 2.5D and 3D but Fusion 360 interface shines for 3D designs while VCarve built-in vector drawing is better for 2.5D
- CNC only and 3D printer as well? Fusion 360 CAD/CAM integration helps
(*) and before someone points out that you can run VCarve in an emulator: that’s effectively running Windows, so different gestures, file system, security, etc. than macOS.